Key takeaways
• Betty Crocker Super Moist Vanilla Mix is the unanimous favorite boxed cake mixture.
• It delivers moist structure, great taste and value. A blind taste test by simply recipes also confirmed that it was the top artist.
Cake mixtures do not take much real estate in my pantry. When it’s time to bake a birthday cake, I turn to the beloved best birthday cake recipe from the infection Kitchen. However, I am far too familiar with the late evening run to the grocery store to pick up a boxed blend and glaze when the inevitable “Oh Shoot, it’s tomorrow?!” happens.
I’ve tried several boxed cake blends, some better than others. I put them all in the same box – good, not big.
Is there a brand out there that is as good as the best homemade vanilla cake? I had to find out, so I reached the pros – and they have opinions. Too dry, too sweet, too artificial, too close, too complicated and not worth the price. The good news is that six bakers and pastry I asked called the same brand as their go-to.
Pro Bakere and Pastry I asked
Just recipes / photo illustration of Wanda Abraham / retailer below
The best boxed cake mixture according to the pros
Despite the many options for boxed cake mixture available on the grocery shelf, a response came back highest: Betty Crocker Super Moist Cake Vanilla Mix. It is loved for its humid structure, delicious taste and affordable price. Sounds like a win-win-win to me!
Not only were the bakers I spoke to, a US shared, but in a taste test for just recipes, Megan Splawn, a professional baker and food editor, tasted seven boxed cake mixtures and came to the same conclusion. Betty Crocker is a winner!
What the pros love about this boxed cake mix
Dorothy loves Betty Crocker for his nostalgic taste: “I love Betty Crocker because it’s the one I grew up using.” This resonates with me. My Aunt Jane’s Baking Creations are the highlights of all our family gatherings, and while she typically depends on her homemade recipes, I recently found her classic coffee cake recipe using Betty Crocker Box Mix as a base. She chooses Betty Crocker because the other popular options taste artificial.
The famous chef and Baker Melissa says, “It’s so hard to choose my favorite box cake mixture; but I feel Betty Crocker Super Moist is taking the cake because it’s not too sweet and super fluffy and bouncing!” It’s an endorsement I take every day.
Lindsey also proved that Betty Crocker super -moist yellow comes out on top in his own taste test. Baking extraordinary Fatima adds, “Notwithstanding the fact that baking a cake from the bottom hits differently, my go-to boxed cake mixture would be Betty Crocker super moist. It reminds me of my childhood!
Like my aunt’s coffee cake technique, many bakers use a boxed blend as a base for a more complicated recipe or doctor up in the boxed blend. Cake Kokk Kennedy says, “My go-to is Betty Crocker. With a small vanilla bean pasta, you would never be able to tell you it wasn’t made from scratch! I use it for something: stored cakes, cake pops, cupcakes! It will melt in your mouth as long as you don’t overpower it.”
The experts have spoken: Of all the boxed cake mixing options, Betty Crocker Super Moist is the one you need to reach.